Carbohydrates have long been considered a key fuel source for athletic performance, especially endurance sports. However, recent research suggests their role in strength training may be more complex. This article explores the latest carbohydrate intake findings for endurance athletes and strength trainers, offering practical insights into how to tailor carbohydrate consumption based on specific training goals.
For endurance athletes, carbohydrates are critical for maintaining energy levels during prolonged physical activity. They provide a readily available source of fuel that can help sustain performance throughout long training sessions or competitions. The general recommendation is to consume around 1.5 grams of carbohydrates per kilogram of body weight within two hours before exercise. This allows athletes to top up their glycogen stores, optimizing endurance performance.
However, consuming too many carbohydrates too close to exercise can overwhelm the gastrointestinal (GI) system, leading to discomfort. Athletes must balance their carbohydrate intake to ensure it fuels their performance without causing digestive issues. Increasing carbohydrate intake beyond the 1.5 grams per kilogram threshold does not appear to provide additional performance benefits. Therefore, athletes should aim for a moderate, manageable intake to fuel their workouts effectively.
In contrast to endurance training, the role of carbohydrates in strength training is less clear. While endurance athletes often depend on carbohydrates to sustain long periods of exercise, strength athletes typically engage in shorter, more intense bouts of effort. The importance of carbohydrate intake in this context has been debated, with some research suggesting that it may not play as crucial a role as once thought.
One study investigated the effects of carbohydrate intake on strength performance. Participants engaged in a 90-minute, full-body strength workout, which included exercises like back squats, bench presses, prone rows, and shoulder presses at 80% of their one-rep max (1RM). These exercises focused on hypertrophy, aiming for 6 to 10 repetitions per set, with participants pushing to failure. The study divided participants into three groups:
All meals were provided as liquid shakes, designed to be identical in taste and texture. Despite the controlled conditions, the study found no significant differences in performance between the groups. Whether participants consumed a high-carb meal, a low-carb meal, or even a placebo, their strength performance, including the number of repetitions and overall exercise output, remained consistent.
Glycogen, the stored form of carbohydrates in muscles, plays an important role in strength and hypertrophy training, particularly in Type II muscle fibers, which are responsible for generating the most force. When glycogen levels are depleted, performance can decline, and the ability to maximize muscle growth is hindered. This makes glycogen essential for sustaining high-intensity training sessions that target muscle growth. While carbohydrate intake may not significantly impact short-term strength performance, it’s essential to consider glycogen depletion. The study by Hockett et al. used a novel technique to examine glycogen depletion in Olympic lifters and found that specific muscle fibers, particularly type II fibers (those used in explosive, high-intensity movements), experienced significant glycogen depletion after moderate volumes of training.
Despite this, overall glycogen depletion appeared modest (around 38%), and the body’s ability to recycle ATP using lactic acid suggested that athletes might not need high levels of carbohydrate intake to maintain performance in strength training. This challenges traditional thinking that high-carb diets are necessary for strength athletes. Hockett’s study suggests that strength athletes can maintain glycogen levels and perform excellently without relying heavily on carbohydrates, provided they have time to recover between sessions.
However, for most lifters, quickly replenishing glycogen post-workout isn’t essential. Even if muscles are completely depleted of glycogen, the body naturally restores these levels within 24 hours, regardless of whether carbohydrates are consumed immediately after exercise. Thus, the urgency of refuelling immediately after a session is often overstated, as glycogen replenishment will occur over time.
Fast glycogen recovery is mainly important for athletes who perform two-a-day workouts, using the same muscles in both sessions. In these cases, replenishing glycogen quickly between sessions is necessary to maintain performance and prevent fatigue.
A meta-analysis examined the effect of carbohydrate intake around resistance training on performance. It found that while carbohydrates improved total training volume, the dose of carbohydrates did not significantly affect performance. This suggests that fuel perception and hunger may be more critical than exact carbohydrate amounts.
Another interesting point is that carbohydrates may have a psychological effect, influencing how athletes feel during training. The mere perception of being fueled by carbohydrates can boost performance, even if the carbohydrate intake is minimal. This placebo effect is essential in sports nutrition, highlighting the complex relationship between diet, performance, and mindset.
Endurance Athletes: Carbohydrates are a vital fuel source for endurance training. Most athletes consume a moderate amount (up to 1.5 grams per kilogram) within two hours before exercise. Avoid excessive carbohydrate intake close to workouts, as this can cause GI discomfort without providing additional benefits.
Strength Athletes: Carbohydrate intake in typical training sessions may not directly impact strength performance. Studies show that high-carb meals before strength training do not significantly enhance performance compared to low-carb or placebo alternatives. However, if an athlete is glycogen-depleted from prior training or has poor energy intake, carbohydrates may help replenish glycogen stores, affecting force production in subsequent sessions.
Individualized Nutrition: Athletes should avoid relying solely on traditional carbohydrate recommendations. Factors like training volume, intensity, meal timing, and individual metabolic responses influence the need for carbohydrates. For many strength athletes, maintaining balanced nutrition throughout the day is more important than acute carbohydrate intake.
Psychological and Perceptual Effects: The perception of carbohydrate availability may influence performance. Athletes should be mindful of the placebo effect and psychology’s role in fueling their training sessions. While carbohydrates are essential for some athletes, the feeling of being fueled can sometimes outweigh the physical need for carbs.
Carbohydrates are essential in endurance sports, but their impact on strength training is less straightforward. Endurance athletes should prioritize carbohydrate intake for sustained energy, while strength athletes may not need to focus as heavily on pre-workout carbohydrates unless they are glycogen-depleted. Athletes should take an individualized approach to carbohydrate intake, considering factors like exercise type, volume, and personal metabolic needs. By doing so, they can optimize their nutrition strategy and perform at their best.
Join my email list to receive updates and information.
